Commentary - May, 2007


IRAQ: “Cut & Run”?, or Take Responsibility? 

Like it or not, this is the question we face in Iraq. This is the hard nut question that we’ve all been trying to crack, for better or worse. Myself, I’ve consistently approached it from the standpoint of another: What’s best for America? On this basis, I’ve come down to a conclusion that, while omitting some important details, can simply summarized: Declare victory, withdraw troops and rely on non-military aid. The latter also rests on the need to pay some attention to something that we all try to teach our kids: responsibility. We may have been wrong to go into Iraq but now, being there, we need to take responsibility for our actions and their consequences.


In particular, if our role in the world as a beacon and promoter of democracy is to mean anything, we need to recognize the need to honor democracy in action, not just words. Our intervention in Iraq has succeeded in establishing a new democratic government in that country; indeed, the FIRST democratic government in the Middle East outside of Israel. But it is a fragile one.


During the recent debate among Republican primary candidates, only one of them, Tommy Thompson, came out with any new ideas on Iraq. One of them is that we should leave Iraq if the new, sovereign Government of Iraq, asks us to. Yet, while recognizing that American withdrawal from Iraq is not just a unilateral, irresponsible “our way or the highway”-type of decision, he didn’t go far enough to honor the democratic idea that we have been working to promote. After all, it is not only Americans who have been losing confidence in the Iraqi government; at least one million Iraqis have “voted with their feet” and left Iraq since the government was formed. Thus, what we need to do is to push the government to hold a democratic referendum on the key question: “America: Go or Stay?” The actual wording of the referendum would probably be subject be some negotiation. The question could also cite “how long?” and/or “benchmarks.”


Remember the three prior Iraqi elections – with Iraqi voter turnouts of over 58% and the purple thumbprints of voters who braved suicide bombers to exercise their right to vote? These inspired many Americans to support a stay in Iraq long enough to help establish a new, democratic government. Now that it has been established, it is time for Iraqis to take responsibility for their own future. Failure of the government to hold a referendum on the “American: go or stay?” issue would itself be a signal that it is time for us to withdraw. The more democratic signal would be the result of a referendum. Are we prepared to accept a democratic result, or do we actually fear the democratic idea that we say we are promoting?


                 PETER BEARSE, Ph.D., Fremont, NH, author of WE THE PEOPLE: A Conservative Populism; 603-819-1408 and/or

More Commentary
April-May, 2007 - A DISLOYAL MAJORITY??
February, 2007 - Global Warming
April-May, 2007 - VICTORY IN IRAQ
April, 2007 - IRAQ
May, 2007 - 2008 Elections
May, 2007 - IRAQ
December, 2006 - REPUBLICAN VISION
June-July, 2007 - Politics & Corruption
August 31-September 15, 2006 - The Global Meaning of 9/11
August 16-25, 2006 - Democracy in Iraq and America
July 28-August 15, 2006 - Lebanon and Iraq: Lessons Alike
Election on Iraq - Get it Right or Get Out
July, 2006 - On the death penalty
July, 2006 - Let's Make It Real!...Compared to What?
July, 2006 - Science & Competitiveness
June 5, 2006 - Redefining the Political Agenda: From Boxes to Loops
May, 2006 - Towards a Better Politics
April 17, 2006 - Reviving Republican Grassroots Politics
#18 November 25, 2005 - This Year & Next
#17 July 27, 2005 - To The Editor, Boston Globe Magazine
#16 May 25, 2005 - Miscellaneous Journal Notes for Writing
#15 May 2-3, 2005 - New Yorker Letters
#14 April 19, 2005 - To The Editor, Rockingham News
#13 April 17, 2005 - Recent Letters to Editors
#12 March 13, 2005 - Two Variations on the Theme of Life
#11 January 31, 2005 - On The Iraqi Elections
#10 January 21, 2005 - Review of the President's Inaugural Address
#9 January 14, 2005 - It's the media, moron!
#8 December 14, 2004 - The American People Regain Political Power by Flying Below the Radar
#7 November 4, 2004 - Election Post-Mortem
#6 October 10, 2004 - Let us all ask two questions
#5 September 4, 2004 - The 2004 political party conventions are finally over
#4 August 1, 2004 - Democratic Convention
#3 July 4, 2004 - FARENHEIT 9/11
#2 June 10, 2004 - Ronald Reagan?s Passing
#1 April 29, 2004 - Political Participation